This Is the Most Forgotten 'American Idol' Winner in the Show’s History

One of the most unique American Idol winners, Caleb Johnson never reached the stardom of previous winners like Kelly Clarkson or Carrie Underwood.

April 13, 2025 · 1 min · 44 words · Robert Foster

Table of Contents

Sadly, Johnson’s misfortune didn’t end there.

The music industry would look different if one Season 1 winner took the crown.

Where Is Johnson Today?

An American Idol silhouette with question marks stands at a mic

Custom Image by Nimesh Perera

Your comment has not been saved

American Idol original judges

Image via FOX

Caleb Johnson singing on American Idol Season 13.

Image via FOX

American Idol Season 21 Poster

ryan-seacrest-at-the-27th-annual-ucla-jonsson-cancer-centre-foundation-s-taste-for-a-cure-event.jpg

Reality TV

American Idol