It’s an awful lot to consider all at once, but consider it we shall!

And she didn’t even have to give anything up for it.

Unfortunately,this exchange does not go unmissed by Freya, who is furious.

Carrie Preston in Elsbeth Season 2 Episode 16

Image via CBS

The next night, Freya and Taylor are having their one-on-one night at a hotel.

She pops bring up the hot tub and is horrified to find him dead inside.

It seems it’s not as cut-and-dry as she first believed.

Mary-Louise Parker in Elsbeth Season 2 Episode 16

Image via CBS

Wagner sends her and Elsbeth back to the scene to see what they missed.

Blanke arrives, needing Wagner’s eyes on something for one of her cases.

Elsbeth assures him she’s got it all taken care of.

Carrie Preston, Micaela Diamond and April Matthis in Elsbeth Season 2 Episode 16

Image via CBS

But given that he was alone, it was unlikely he’d kill the lid on himself.

Wagner agrees once Tub Top agrees to cover the costs of the test, and the representatives are dismissed.

Give my regards to Broadway!

Carrie Preston as Elsbeth Tascioni smiling off camera in a bar setting

Wagner admits to not getting the whole idea of throuples, sounding very judgmental in the process.

For him, this is too much, and a sign that the relationship is moving too fast.

He tells Teddy he has until the end of his visit to decide what he wants to do.

elsbeth-mary-louise-parker-carrie-preston

Image via Michael Parmelee/CBS

With Cameron gone too, Elsbeth returns to examining the real estate on her screen.

Taylor agrees to keep it quiet, but it’s obviously haunting her.

Elsbeth reminds him that wrong choices happen, and what matters is that he is the one making them.

Elsbeth 2024 TV Series Poster

And just like that, the whole case clicks for Elsbeth.

Cameron pulls Kaya’s birthday off beautifully.

New episodes ofElsbethSeason 2 premiere Thursdays on CBS.

instar53849722.jpg

Cast Placeholder Image

Elsbeth

Mary-Louise Parker