Those who love cinema and film criticism should be more than familiar enough withRoger EbertandGene Siskel.

But any good show requires drama, and as it happens,Siskel & Eberthad plenty of it.

Sometimes, those disagreements made for some really solid entertainment.

10 Movies That Gene Siskel and Roger Ebert Strongly Disagreed On

Custom Image by Zanda Rice

Though the Academy seemed to disagree, one can see where they’re coming from.

Of course, such a cultural phenomenon couldn’t go without aSiskel & Ebertreview.

Time has definitely sided with Ebert much more so than with Siskel on this one.

Ned Logan and William Munny, riding horses and looking to the distance in Unforgiven

Image via Warner Bros. Pictures

Siskel, on the other hand, would beg to differ.

Ebert, on the other hand, thought it was pretty good for what it was trying to achieve.

As it happens, Ebert and Siskel couldn’t seem to agree on it.

Unforgiven Movie Poster

Ebert wasone of the people who pushed this consensus, while Siskel fought against it.

Although history has sided with Ebert, it’s not impossible to see where Siskel is coming from.

Siskel, while agreeing with Ebert that the script had no surprises, didn’t mind nearly as much.

instar50562789.jpg

Siskel, on the other hand, said he “didn’t like the movie at all.”

These victories must have surely made Roger Ebert quite happy.

Siskel, not so much.

instar48992070.jpg

However,Blue Velvetwas one that the duo disagreed on.

KEEP READING:Top Non-Disney Animated Movies Roger Ebert Loved

R. Lee Ermey as Gunnery Sergeant Hartman, pointing a finger at the camera in ‘Full Metal Jacket’

Image via Warner Bros. Pictures

01141887_poster_w780.jpg

instar52457620.jpg

instar49763700.jpg

Jeff Bridges and Steve Buscemi look at John Goodman while in a bowling alley in ‘The Big Lebowski’ (1998)

Image via Gramercy Pictures

the-big-lebowski-movie-poster.jpg

instar53764142.jpg

instar53745383.jpg

A boy next to the dragon Flakor in The NeverEnding Story

Image via Warner Bros. Pictures

The Neverending Story Movie Poster

instar43842961.jpg

Cast Placeholder Image

Fa Mulan disguised as a male soldier, holds her jian sword vertically in front of her face

Image via Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

Mulan 1998 Movie Poster

instar53583089-1.jpg

instar53258501.jpg

instar51644307.jpg

instar46914285.jpg

Siisy Spacek as Carrie White in Carrie

Image via United Artists

0168017_poster_w780.jpg

instar49664544.jpg

Tom Cruise as Lieutenant Kaffee saluting in uniform in A Few Good Men

Image via Columbia Pictures

a few good man poster

instar52837500.jpg

instar49054663.jpg

Al Pacino as Tony Montana shooting a rifle in ‘Scarface’.

Image via Universal Pictures

scarface-movie-poster.jpg

instar50904598.jpg

instar53405948.jpg

Hannibal Lecter is shown in reflection of his glass cell as Clarice Starling looks on in Silence of the Lambs

Image via Orion Pictures

the-silence-of-the-lambs-poster.jpg

instar53504210.jpg

instar51354110.jpg

Laura Dern and Isabella Rossellini looking over at Kyle MacLachlan in ‘Blue Velvet’

Image via De Laurentiis Entertainment Group

blue-velvet-movie-poster.jpg

instar53512764.jpg

instar53620830.jpg

Movie

Roger Ebert