What does it mean a movie’s ending doesn’t “hold up?”

For films that are adaptations of historical events or public figures, it gets even more complicated.

As his rampage continues throughout Haddonfield, the citizens of the small town take notice.

Rosamund Pike, Richard E. Grant, Barry Keoghan, Jacob Elrodi, Alison Oliver, and Archie Madekwe on the poster for Saltburn

Image via Amazon MGM Studios

Throughout the evening, a mob forms and sets out to hunt Michael down.

For some, it’s an interesting and effective way to utilize a popular genre.

In the case ofHalloween Kills, this approach felt like too little too late.

Judy Greer, Jamie Lee Curtis, and Andi Matichak looking tired while on the back of a truck in Halloween Kills

Image via Universal Pictures

But when it seems like the credits are about to roll forAmerican Sniper, a surprise second ending begins.

This vestigial coda explores Kyle’s post-war activities assisting disenfranchised veterans, one of whom would ultimately kill him.

This journey into his post-war altruism isso heavy-handed it feels disingenuously saccharine.

Halloween Kills Movie Poster

Whether Shyamalan intended to reckon with such nuance is irrelevant because no such reckoning was borne out on screen.

Instead, audiences are left with two-thirds of a thrilling movie anda very sloppy ending.

Felix invites Oliver to spend the summer holiday at his family’s expansive country estate, the titularSaltburn.

Bradley Cooper as Chris Kyle aiming a rifle over a wall of sandbags in American Sniper

Image via Warner Bros.

Audiences would likely say, “All the supporting characters in the film are apes.

The premise and plot of the film involve sentient apes.

Is it supposed to be surprising that he is surrounded by apes?”

american-sniper-poster-1.jpg

That’s the film’s whole point!

That’s essentially what it feels like to watchSaltburn’s third act.

The attention was likely due to the film’s embracing of New Extremity.

Carey Mulligan as Cassie sitting on a couch in Promising Young Woman

Image via Focus Features

In fact, it renders most of the film nonsensical in terms of its chronology and logic.

As the minutes tick by,The Substancecontinues to pass over opportunities to explore other aspects of its theme.

Instead,its profoundly unsubtle message is emphasized over and over againin increasingly indelicate ways.

promising-young-woman-movie-poster.jpg

The film’s exploration of generational misogyny seems interesting at first glance.

However,writer-directorAlex Garlanddoesn’t seem to have more than a rudimentary perspective on it.

Moments before the pair begin the procedure, Audrey backs out, and Paul shrinks alone.

Guy Cappa and two women behind him looking ahead with shocked expressions in Old - 2021

Image via Universal Picture

Few films have been done as dirty by their marketing asDownsizing.

Instead, audiences got a boring and preachy film that had little to do with being shrunk.

NEXT:15 Great Movies Ruined by Awful Endings

old-movie-poster.jpg

Barry Keoghan’s Oliver Quick in Saltburn looking over a balcony.

Image via MGM

Saltburn 2023 Movie Poster

Marie (Cécile de France), covered in blood, holds a chainsaw, in ‘High Tension’.

Image via EuropaCorp

high-tension-movie-poster.jpg

Demi Moore poster looking over Margaret Qualley in ‘The Substance’

Image via Mubi

the-substance-2024-official-poster.jpg

A person with a mask on of a blonde-haired woman

Image via A24

a24-men-keyartvrt-rgb.jpg

Kristen Wiig and Matt Damon as Audrey and Paul smiling while looking down at two miniature people waving Downsizing

Image via Paramount Pictures

downsizing-movie-poster.jpg

The cast of The Trial of the Chicago 7 seated at the defense table in the courtroom

Image via Netflix

the-trial-of-the-chicago-7-movie-poster.jpg

Movie

Saltburn

Downsizing